New Smyrna Beach offers a slice of pizza paradise for every palate. From classic New York-style pies to gourmet creations, this Florida town serves up a diverse array of pizza joints. Let’s explore ten top-notch spots to get pizza in New Smyrna Beach that keep locals and visitors coming back for more. Grab a napkin – it’s time to dig in!

Panheads Pizzeria

Panheads Pizzeria brings a slice of rock ‘n’ roll to New Smyrna Beach’s pizza scene. This joint dishes out generously topped hand-tossed pizza in NSB. Their signature crust, a perfect balance of crispy and chewy, serves as a canvas for fresh ingredients. Locals rave about the “Jam Band” pizza, loaded with an array of meats and veggies. Vegetarians can groove to the “Acoustic” pizza, featuring a medley of garden-fresh toppings. Beyond pizzas, Panheads offers hearty subs and crisp salads. The atmosphere is casual and fun, adorned with music memorabilia. It’s a go-to spot for families, friends, and solo diners alike. On weekends, catch live music while munching on your favorite slice. Outdoor seating allows pizza lovers to enjoy their meal in the Florida sunshine. Panheads Pizzeria hits all the right notes for pizza enthusiasts in New Smyrna Beach.

Baci Pizzeria Ristorante

Baci Pizzeria Ristorante brings a taste of Italy to New Smyrna Beach. This family-owned establishment prides itself on authentic Italian recipes passed down through generations. Their pizza dough, made fresh daily, results in a crust that’s both thin and flavorful. Baci’s Margherita pizza, topped simply with tomatoes, mozzarella, and basil, showcases the quality of their ingredients. For those craving heartier options, the meat lover’s pizza satisfies every carnivore’s dream. The restaurant’s cozy interior, reminiscent of a traditional Italian trattoria, adds to the dining experience. Beyond pizzas, Baci offers a full Italian menu including pasta dishes and seafood specialties. Their wine list features selections that pair perfectly with pizzas. Baci’s warm service and attention to detail have earned them a loyal following among locals and tourists alike. It’s a slice of Italy right in New Smyrna Beach.

Tiano’s Italian Restaurant

Tiano’s Italian Restaurant has been serving up delicious pizzas and Italian fare in New Smyrna Beach for years. Their pizzas feature a perfect balance of sauce, cheese, and toppings on a crust that’s crispy on the outside and soft on the inside. The Sicilian pizza, a house specialty, boasts a thick, square crust topped generously. For those who prefer thinner crusts, the New York-style pizzas hit the spot. Tiano’s also caters to dietary restrictions offering gluten-free options. The restaurant’s casual, family-friendly atmosphere makes it ideal for group gatherings or family dinners. Their extensive menu goes beyond pizzas, featuring pasta dishes, calzones, and strombolis. Don’t miss their garlic knots – a perfect starter while waiting for your pizza. Tiano’s commitment to quality ingredients and traditional recipes keeps patrons coming back for more.

The Original Stavro’s Pizza

The Original Stavro’s Pizza has been a New Smyrna Beach staple for decades. This no-frills pizzeria focuses on what matters most – great pizza. Their hand-tossed dough, made fresh daily, forms the foundation of every pie. Stavro’s sauce, a secret family recipe, strikes the perfect balance between tangy and sweet. Generous portions of high-quality toppings complete each pizza. The “Supreme” pizza, loaded with a variety of meats and veggies, is a crowd favorite. For cheese lovers, the “Four Cheese” pizza doesn’t disappoint. Stavro’s also offers a selection of subs and salads. The casual, laid-back atmosphere reflects the beach town vibe. It’s common to see sandy-footed beachgoers grabbing a slice or two. Stavro’s commitment to consistency and quality has earned them a loyal following among locals and tourists alike.

Flagler Avenue Pizza Company

Flagler Avenue Pizza Company sits in the heart of New Smyrna Beach’s bustling Flagler Avenue. This pizzeria combines traditional techniques and modern flavors to create unique pies. Their thin-crust pizzas, baked to perfection in a brick oven, boast a satisfying crunch. The “Beach Bum” pizza, topped sundried tomatoes, feta, and spinach, is a local favorite. For adventurous eaters, the “Surf’s Up” pizza features a surprising yet delicious combination of shrimp and pesto. The restaurant’s beach-themed decor adds to the fun, relaxed atmosphere. Besides pizzas, they offer a selection of craft beers to complement your meal. Outdoor seating allows diners to people-watch while enjoying their slice. Flagler Avenue Pizza Company’s prime location and creative menu make it a popular choice for both locals and beach visitors.

Caffé Vesuvio

Caffé Vesuvio brings a taste of Naples to New Smyrna Beach. This authentic Italian eatery takes pride in its Neapolitan-style pizzas, baked in a wood-fired oven imported from Italy. The result is a pizza soft and slightly charred crust, topped with ingredients sourced directly from Italy. Their Margherita DOC pizza, made San Marzano tomatoes and buffalo mozzarella, transports diners straight to Naples. For those seeking bolder flavors, the “Diavola” pizza packs a spicy punch. The restaurant’s intimate setting, Italian decor, and soft lighting create a romantic atmosphere. Beyond pizzas, Caffé Vesuvio offers a range of Italian dishes and an extensive wine list. Their gelato, made in-house, provides a sweet ending to your meal. Caffé Vesuvio offers an authentic Italian dining experience in the heart of New Smyrna Beach.

Beachside Pizza

Beachside Pizza lives up to its name, offering tasty pies just steps from the sand. This casual joint is a favorite among surfers and beach-goers looking for a quick, satisfying meal. Their pizzas feature a medium-thick crust that holds up well to a variety of toppings. The “Beachside Special,” loaded with pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, and extra cheese, is a popular choice. Vegetarians will appreciate the “Garden Delight” pizza, packed with fresh veggies. In addition to whole pies, Beachside Pizza offers pizza by the slice – perfect for a quick beach snack. The no-frills interior is brightened by beach-themed murals. Outdoor seating allows diners to enjoy the ocean breeze with their meal. Beachside Pizza’s convenient location and wallet-friendly prices make it a go-to spot for pizza lovers in New Smyrna Beach.

Prima

Prima elevates the pizza experience in New Smyrna Beach, offering gourmet pies in an upscale setting. Their artisanal approach to pizza-making results in unique flavor combinations that tantalize the taste buds. The dough, made using a blend of flours and allowed to ferment for 48 hours, creates a crust both flavorful and easily digestible. Prima’s “Fig and Prosciutto” pizza, drizzled balsamic glaze, is a standout. For truffle enthusiasts, the “Funghi” pizza, topped with wild mushrooms and truffle oil, is a must-try. The restaurant’s sleek, modern interior provides a sophisticated dining atmosphere. Prima also boasts an impressive wine list and craft cocktail menu. Their commitment to using locally sourced, organic ingredients whenever possible appeals to health-conscious diners. Prima offers a refined pizza dining experience in New Smyrna Beach.

Mickey’s Pizza

Mikey’s Pizza has been serving up classic New York-style slices to New Smyrna Beach for a good while now. This family-owned pizzeria prides itself on big, foldable slices thin, crispy crust. Their sauce, made from vine-ripened tomatoes, strikes the perfect balance of sweet and tangy. Mickey’s “Grandma Pizza,” a thin-crust square pie topped garlic, olive oil, and plum tomatoes, is a local favorite. For those who like it hot, the “Buffalo Chicken” pizza packs a spicy kick. The casual, no-frills atmosphere keeps the focus on the food. Besides pizzas, Mickey’s offers a variety of Italian-American classics like calzones and strombolis. Their garlic knots, always served hot and fresh, are the perfect starter. Mickey’s convenient location and late hours make it a popular choice for both lunch crowds and late-night snackers.

Pizza And More

Pizza And More offers a wide variety of pizzas and Italian-American favorites. Their pizzas feature a medium-thick crust with heavy abd light options. The “Works” pizza, loaded with multiple meats and veggies, is perfect for those who want it all. Lighter options like the “Spinach and Feta” pizza cater to health-conscious diners. As the name suggests, Pizza And More goes beyond just pies – their menu includes pasta dishes, subs, and wings. The restaurant’s family-friendly atmosphere makes it a popular choice for group dinners. They offer a lunch buffet during weekdays, allowing diners to sample various pizzas and sides. Pizza And More’s diverse menu and generous portions have made it a staple in New Smyrna Beach’s dining scene.

New Smyrna Beach Pizza Specialties

New Smyrna Beach pizzerias often incorporate local flavors into their pies. Many spots offer seafood toppings like fresh shrimp or clams, reflecting the town’s coastal location. Some pizzerias experiment with seasonal ingredients, creating limited-time offerings based on what’s available locally. Keep an eye out for pizzas featuring Florida citrus-infused sauces or locally grown vegetables. These unique creations showcase the area’s culinary creativity and connection to its seaside roots.

Vacation with Great Ocean Condos & Homes

New Smyrna Beach’s pizza scene offers variety and quality. Each pizzeria brings its unique flavor to the table, catering to different tastes and preferences. These ten spots represent the cream of the crop, serving up slices that keep the town’s pizza lovers satisfied.

For your stay in New Smyrna Beach, check out Great Ocean Condos and Homes. We offer comfortable accommodations close to these fantastic pizzerias, ensuring a perfect beach getaway.